The Fog of War
I'm trying to be a responsible, educated voter. So I watched tonight's South Carolina debate, really the first of this campaign I've tuned in for.
Assuming, for a moment, that you may also be choosing your likely November vote (to say nothing of, perhaps, a Super Tuesday vote) from among the three people on that stage -- do you find these useful? Are they informative? If not, is there somewhere else from which it is better to get one's information on what the policies, likely intentions, and guiding philosophies of the candidates are? Mind you, I know I could go to the candidates websites, and I intend to. But I suppose I'm pessimistic about getting help there.
Much of what I read -- even on sites dedicated to the minutae of presidential politics -- seems to be focused on the horse race aspect, and to the "electibility" questions. Who is "tough enough" to survive the general election? Who will discover their "voice?" Etc., etc. Nothing that helps me decide who I want to be running the show.
In the past several elections, my electoral choices seemed to have been made for me by preceding events. But while I presume that Hillary Clinton has an enormous advantage in the Democratic primary in New York, it hardly seems like a foregone conclusion. So I'm forced to feel that my vague and hard-to-explain political leanings, this time around, will not be enough.
Does anyone out there feel the same way? How have you coped?
Comments
Since the only candidate who shares my views on issues including Kyoto, Iraq/Iran, the Patriot Act, death penalty, health care, gay marriage, etc. was Kucinich, I supported him. Even though I knew he'd be shut out, just to have a brief feeling that this election is relevant to me. The other 3 Dems are too much alike in the "I don't trust them" way, so once again, my vote will be "a vote against" some Republican with scary religious views, etc. We really need a parliamentary system.
Posted by: shananan
|
January 22, 2008 07:44 AM
Hmm.
Well, it's helped me to realize
the president really has no control over many issues, except as a 'bully pulpit' (any issue that requires constitutional change, like gun control or gay marriage).
It also helped me to realize that what I most dislike about the current president is not his insane positions, but HOW he came to those positions. His decision-making process (decide the truth first, based on either nothing or what someone with influence told him, then tell people to gather 'things' (I hesitate to even call it evidence) to support that position) is the single thing that makes him the worst administration of my lifetime.
So I look less for issue positions than I used to - I trust that any Dem candidate will be more fiscally responsible, take our commitment to our soldiers more seriously, nominate supremes who believe habeas corpus is a good thing, etc. What I'm looking for in debates now is how they explain why they hold the positions they hold, and when they tell their little stories of how they saved orphaned puppies from legislation that would have turned them into clay pigeons for Republican donors, to hear HOW they made that come about.
Hope that helps.
Posted by: boxjam
|
January 22, 2008 10:35 AM
Remember that the Democratic primaries aren't winner-take-all, so even if H. Clinton has a big lead, you can vote meaningfully for B. Obama, since delegate count looks like it will actually matter this year. (Or even J. Edwards if you want him to be kingmaker.)
Posted by: gavinedwards
|
January 22, 2008 02:50 PM
Happy belated LBJ day.
Posted by: herbivorous
|
January 22, 2008 11:14 PM
shit -- i missed the NH primary! why was it so early this year?
Posted by: art
|
January 23, 2008 05:58 AM
Art, many states kept pushing forward their primaries, in an effort to become more influential by being early. Iowa and New Hampshire kept moving theirs to remain first. This has had odd side effects, including disqualification of delegates from Michigan and Florida, after they violated the Dem Party's cutoff date, and the outsize influence of states that =didn't= move to Super Tuesday, because for once, the race may extend all the way to the convention.
Posted by: gavinedwards
|
January 24, 2008 08:23 PM