May 06, 2002
Aslan Revisited

As recently discussed in this space, I've been on the receiving end of quite a few items from the old homestead of late. (Yes, the Legos arrived.) Most recently, the UPS truck brought a package containing a battered but complete set of the Chronicles of Narnia.

It's safe to say that The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe was my first truly compelling experience with narrative fantasy. The first time Iread them through I was simply beguiled by the whole package: the journey to another world, getting to be knights with swords, talking animals, and the most competent parent-figure ever invented in literature. By the time I got the news that there was a layer of Christian allegory rather smoothly woven throughout, I was too happy with Lewis's world to mind very much -- it made a touch less personally magical, but later added a certain level of interpretive puzzle to work on. Even Lewis's version of the Apocalypse seemed more reassuring than the grotesque vision of the Rapture that sprung up in the evangelical pamphlets I found in my friends' homes.

Rereading the books now, two things strike me as worthy of comment. The first is how much Lewis owed to (and attempted to transform) the rhetoric and setting of Victorian and Edwardian books of the post-Tom Brown's School Days variety. The moral lessons imparted to children in Narnia distinctly partake of the fair-play, no-squealing ethos of the boarding school world. While the narrative frame of The Silver Chair is explicitly concerned with the tyranny of school bullies, Lewis's children in general must learn to suffer their privations with honor, and though he doesn't blame them for crying when homesick, he privileges "pluck" over tenderness.

Leaving behind Lewis's didactic concerns, though, what's striking in comparison to the work of a contemporary and friend is how narratively speedy Lewis is. The man knows how to keep a story going, and though he'll pause a moment or two to remind one of how impressive Aslan's mane or the deliciousness of a large breakfast (Never was there a fantasy series so repeatedly devoted to the pleasure of a big breakfast, by the way. More of the scarring of the old public school education of poor old Clive, one supposes), there's little lingering. Event follows event, Narnia is saved ---and before one knows it, it's a quick lecture from Aslan, and back through the bloody wardrobe. It's a good thing he turned out a whole pile of these books, or he'd have had a lot of very frustrated children on his hands. And please don't tell me to follow the last one with a romp through Mere Christianity. In case you didn't know, the Lion ain't in it.

Posted by BT at May 06, 2002 06:01 PM
Comments

> Narnia is saved

Well, now I guess I don't have to finish reading what I started about 20+ years ago.

Posted by: teenidol on May 6, 2002 11:02 PM

Sorry, James. I should have put in a spoiler warning!

Posted by: Bt on May 6, 2002 11:49 PM

I haven't reread the Chronicles o' N again as an adult, though it took me a long time to get over my grudge against Harry Potter after I read an article which quoted one mother, who, at the midnight madness accompanying the release of HP2, said in praise of Mr. Potter "Now kids don't have to read those horrid Narnia books anymore."

Aslan dissin' ho, you'd better hope we never meet.

Posted by: scott on May 7, 2002 09:21 AM

I loved the Narnia books as a child, and the discovery of the Christian themes of Narnia was an absolutely pivotal moment in my history of reading. Around ninth grade or so, when I read Lewis alluding to the parallels in letters he wrote to child fans, I was faced with the notion that a book could contain many things, some of which could remain hidden for years--had been secret for my whole life, as far as I was concerned.

Posted by: Gavin on May 7, 2002 10:43 AM

Also: the recent renumbering of the series, so that it now begins with The Magician's Nephew? An utter abomination.

Posted by: Gavin on May 7, 2002 10:44 AM

Not nearly the abomination that the porn titles taken from "Narnia" are.

"Voyage of the Dawn Spreader" indeed.

Posted by: bup on May 7, 2002 01:02 PM